Manchester United are reportedly close to securing the signing of midfielder Andrey Santos, but the deal has sparked concern among club legends Paul Scholes and Nicky Butt. Both former players have expressed doubts about Santos’ suitability for the Red Devils, especially given the £50 million package that is expected to see him join the club after completing a medical.
According to Football365, the highly-rated Brazilian could be signing for United as early as Friday, with Fabrizio Romano confirming the completion of his medical and the finalisation of documents. This follows United’s strategy of targeting at least two to three midfielders this summer while trying to avoid excessive fees for players such as Elliot Anderson and Sandro Tonali.
Concerns Over Santos’ Attributes
Despite Santos’ imminent arrival, Butt has shown scepticism about his impact, saying that “nothing stands out” regarding the midfielder’s abilities. He remarked that, at £25-30 million, the signing would seem reasonable, but at £50 million, it raises questions about whether he will be able to contribute greatly. Butt’s past performances with Chelsea, including only 13 starts last season, do not inspire confidence in his capacity to excel at Old Trafford.
Scholes Questions the transfer Strategy
Scholes has echoed Butt’s sentiments, adding a cautionary note regarding United’s approach to building the squad. He noted the importance of re-signing established players rather than someone perceived as an unproven talent. “Why are Chelsea selling him, a 22-year-old kid?” Scholes questioned, highlighting the lack of excitement surrounding the potential transfer and the urgent need for players who can make an immediate impact.
Butt’s View on Midfield Needs
Butt expressed that he would feel more comfortable with Santos’ signing if the club were simultaneously pursuing a midfielder with proven quality, ideally one who commands around £100 million. He remarked on the successful performances of players like Matheus Fernandes and Tonali in the league, raising concerns that United might be settling for potential rather than the proven quality needed for immediate success.
The SportiveNews view
This potential transfer hinges on United’s broader strategic vision for squad enhancement. Santos represents a gamble on potential, but the club is under pressure to improve its midfield urgently. The upcoming season demands readiness, as United will compete in multiple tournaments; thus, a reliance on young talent might not be the best approach for immediate gains.
Frequently asked questions
Why are Scholes and Butt critical of the Santos signing?
Both Scholes and Butt have raised concerns regarding Santos’ capabilities and the price tag associated with the deal, suggesting that his limited appearances last season may not justify the £50 million fee.
What is the timeline for Andrey Santos’s potential signing?
The expectation is that Santos will officially join Manchester United on Friday, following the completion of his medical and the formalities of the contract, with reports indicating all documents have been signed.
For more on this and other transfers, be sure to check our latest Premier League transfer news. For comprehensive football coverage, visit our Premier League coverage.
More from SportiveNews: Premier League transfer news · Premier League coverage